, ,

The Real Scandal of Clinton State Department: Wage Suppression in Haiti

The first black nation to overthrow its colonial masters still enslaves 300,000 of its children. Unlike the initial slavery which gave birth to Haiti, this slavery is not a result of kidnapping or intertribal warfare but poverty.

In an island with a population of 6 million, 300,000 children perform unpaid labor because their parents are simply too poor to care of them. Thus, they are given to families slightly better off than themselves where they work in an unregulated market for food and shelter. These vulnerable children are the face of Haitian poverty.

Thanks to the tireless efforts of millennials who do their research, it has now become well-known that Hillary Clinton, in her role as secretary of state, intervened in the internal politics of Haiti to prevent the government from raising the minimum wage $.24 per hour to $.61 per hour.

That the American government throws its weight around to oppress the poor around the world is not news to the poor around the world. Americans of good conscience are rightly appalled that their government was used to keep this desperately poor nation from taking this small step to improve their lives of its people. The Haitian parliament unanimously voted for the wage increase only to be informed by their neo-colonial masters, “You’re not in charge.” For those African-Americans fond of opining about black diaspora solidarity, moments like this are opportunities for critical decision points.

However, from the perspective of America interest and democracy, the humiliation and exploitation of Haitians by Clinton’s state department is not the real scandal. The real scandal is that the American government has constituents–and it ain’t us.

The aspect of this story that should trouble Americans is how responsive the government can be to the requests of Americans when those Americans are wealthy corporations even when the requests being made by these corporations undermine the interest of American workers.

Free trade brought American corporations like Hanes and Levi Strauss to Haiti. They went there for cheap labor. At the time of Clinton’s helpful intervention, there were 25,000 garment workers and a wage increase would have cost $12.5 million for the sector, which brings in billions a year. The CEO of Hanes alone made $10 million; the increase would have cost the company $1.6 million.

These billions are only benefitting a handful of Americans, and yet, the state department took proactive steps to override the will of the people of Haiti as expressed by their representatives and succeeded.

It’s not just the will of Haitians that the U.S. government ignores but of Americans. Americans who want firearm legislation cannot get it through Congress; Americans who want single payer health care are told it’s too hard; Americans opposed to military actions in Syria were ignored.

Yet, when a handful of corporations who want to keep wages low seek actions from their government, their government represents their interests. Can any American earning a five-figure salary imagine getting that sort of response from our government?

However, even that is only half of the scandal. Given the constant bleeding of American jobs to places like Haiti, how does it benefit American workers to keep wages in third world countries low?

From January 2008 to April 2015, about 86,800 jobs (or 39%) in the U.S. apparel manufacturing sector had disappeared. These jobs continue to be shipped abroad because free trade deals have made it lucrative for companies to outsource jobs to places where labor is cheap but to sell goods to places where consumer prices are high.

A State Department invested in the interest of ordinary Americans would have told the garment manufacturers if they don’t like Haiti’s new minimum wage laws, they can bring the 25,000 jobs back to the United States. Instead, Clinton took steps to maintain the very conditions that make outsourcing so attractive to corporations.

Who does our government work for? Who will Hillary Clinton work for?


Carolyn Hyppolite is a Guest Contributor to Progressive Army.

5 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
Bernie Wasn't The Chosen One: That's Why He Mattered | The Progressive ArmyKristine BlakeKurt YoungSharon WheelerAmanda Dustin Hancock Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Kristine Blake

Bernie Sanders is spot on when he speaks of outsourced job, and Hilary’s ties to TTP & minimum wage, In the US she thought $15.00 was too high. She thought $12.00 would be enough, and meanhile, several states including California, have raised it to $15.00 an hour! #FeelTheBern has it right. Forget his “tone”, as she has her own negative “tone” shining through.

Kurt Young

This was part of PL 110-246, HR 6124, which was passed in 2008 to help “stablize” the Haitian economy. I was voted for by 75 US Senators including Bernie. Hillary actually opposed it and didn’t vote for it. Whoppsie. Fell the Burned. Try reading the congressional record sometime. I love Bernie, and will vote for him if he wins the Democratic Nomintation, but his followers have created this mythical figure and turned Hillary into this she demon.

Amanda Dustin Hancock

What about giving her bother, the rights to Haitian gold mines? Can we say…. Corrupt!

Sharon Wheeler

remember, when 6 billion went missing under her leadership…she is careless, and did it go into her pocket?


[…] out because her faults ruin their One True Hero narrative. Clearly, she can’t be a villain that opposes minimum wages for people of color, because that’s not what feminist heroes do. If you pay attention to the people back home in the […]

[WATCH] Black Girls Rock, Ms. Millie, and Respecting Space

The Real Scandal of Clinton State Department: Wage Suppression in Haiti